A True Story of Survival, Leadership, and Hope: Island of the lost

Book Review: 'Island of the Lost' by Joan Druett – A Remarkable Tale of Survival and Brotherhood

Stranded on the Edge of the World

Auckland Island is a godforsaken place in the middle of the Southern Ocean, 285 miles south of New Zealand. 

With year-round freezing rain, howling winds, and no access to rescue or supplies, it stands among the harshest environments on Earth. To be shipwrecked there meant almost certain death.

In 1864, Captain Thomas Musgrave and his crew of four aboard the schooner Grafton found themselves wrecked on the southern end of this desolate island.

With no hope of immediate rescue, they faced not only the elements but also the psychological toll of isolation.

Survival Through Leadership and Ingenuity

Utterly alone in a dense coastal forest plagued by blowflies and relentless cold rain, Captain Musgrave’s leadership became the key to survival.

 

With nothing but determination and teamwork, the crew built a weatherproof cabin and even managed to construct a functioning forge, crafting tools that would help them endure months of isolation.

Their story is one of perseverance, resourcefulness, and mutual respect. It’s a vivid demonstration of how strong leadership and unity can help people overcome seemingly impossible odds.

A Tale of Two Crews, Two Fates

What adds a fascinating layer to this book is the contrast between two different shipwrecked crews on opposite ends of Auckland Island. 

While Musgrave's team pulled together, another group of sailors, stranded around the same time, experienced chaos and tragedy.

Joan Druett’s account highlights how leadership, mindset, and group cohesion can define survival. 

This comparison deepens the narrative, making it more than just a survival tale—it’s a study of human nature.

Powerful Characters and Real Emotions

You will absolutely fall in love with the characters. The author does an amazing job of bringing these real historical figures to life. 

Captain Musgrave and François Raynal, in particular, are portrayed with depth and authenticity. Their courage, humanity, and emotional strength leave a lasting impact.

Druett tells the story in an almost day-by-day format, making you feel as if you’re experiencing the events alongside them. 

Her attention to detail is remarkable, drawing from journals, survivor accounts, and historical press articles.

A Glimpse Into 19th-Century Seafaring

The book offers a rich insight into life at sea before the age of steam engines.

It captures how men navigated using stars, battled wild ocean storms, and maintained strict naval hierarchy, even while wearing rags and nearing starvation. 

It’s an extraordinary portrayal of life during a time when the ocean was both a livelihood and a deadly frontier.

I became a big fan of Joan Druett with this book! The smooth narration, the incredible attention to detail, and the events of the 1800s themselves blend to form a fantastic read.'

An Inspiring Read That Picks Up Pace

Admittedly, the first couple of chapters may feel a bit slow as the historical context is set.

But stick with it—once the story gains momentum, it becomes a compelling and emotionally powerful narrative that you won’t want to put down.

Final Thoughts: A Must-Read Tale of Survival and Brotherhood

Island of the Lost is more gripping than fiction—because it’s real. It’s a tribute to human resilience, leadership, and the power of working together. As someone who enjoys stories of history, survival, and human endurance, I found this book unforgettable.

Highly recommended for readers who love true survival stories, maritime history, or simply a moving story of people who refused to give up.

All in all, an inspiring story of survival and grit. Highly recommend it.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR 

Joan Druett is a New Zealand-based maritime historian and award-winning author known for her captivating nonfiction and historical fiction works centered on life at sea. With a deep passion for nautical history, she has written extensively about sailors, shipwrecks, and maritime exploration. Her meticulous research and vivid storytelling have earned her international acclaim, especially for books like Island of the Lost and She Captains. Druett’s work brings forgotten seafaring stories to life, combining historical accuracy with compelling narrative.

Get your copy on Amazon

                                      

                

(This post may contain affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate, I earn from qualifying purchases. This does not affect your price.)